The World Bank’s Nature-Based Tourism (NBT) Community of Practice commissioned a
comprehensive
review of the tools and knowledge resources with the aim of helping WBG staff prepare and
implement better projects. The objectives were to:
-
provide a comprehensive review established NBT resources (i.e. guidelines, “how-to”, best
practices) to help nature-based tourism practitioners to understand better the key issues
relating to NBT, including the diversity of activities, alternative approaches, and best
practices.
-
generate a consolidated list of tools and resources that are available
-
identify gaps in knowledge.
An online literature review combined with online consultation survey with over 112
practitioners elicited over 360 technical resources and institutions working on NBT.
Highlights
of the analysis include:
-
A review of
international agreements that NBT contribute to, including frameworks and decisions of the
United Nations (UN), the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD), the UN Educational,
Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and the UN World Tourism Organization (UNWTO).
-
A compendium of best practice guidance on NBT, including guidelines, case studies, and
books
established for different parts of the world, and a variety of types of NBT (e.g. wildlife
tourism, hunting, marine tourism, and forest areas).
-
Toolkits that support NBT planning for destinations and also enterprises, including
step-by-step processes, practical examples and templates.
-
Enabling policy environment and planning resources, including guidelines, manuals,
handbooks,
strategies and examples of policy instruments.
-
Concessioning and partnership tools to that help destination managers, including guidance
on
institutional frameworks that boost partnerships with local communities.
-
Destination management resources including background reading resources in key issues,
case
study examples of good practices, and practical tools.
-
Guidance on the development of infrastructure and facilities that support conservation
objectives, including for
accommodation (e.g. lodges, campsites, cabins), access (e.g. roads, hiking trails,
boardwalks,
bridges, signage), experiences (e.g. cliff and treetop walks, mooring points, viewpoints,
visitor centres) and provide support (e.g. retail and catering facilities)
.
-
Principles and frameworks for visitor management, coupled with practical tools and
guidelines.
-
Information for individuals and enterprising that want to plan, design and operate NBT
sustainably, with materials relevant for different countries and types of NBT (e.g.
community-based NBT, adventure tourism, geotourism, and tourism indifferent
ecosystems).
-
Materials that provide comprehensive analyses of the impacts of NBT on
natural resources, local economies, culture and society, and tourists – and also links to
resources and tools that can be used to maximize the net-benefits of NBT.
-
Guidance, tools and strategies for both risk management and monitoring and evaluation for
NBT,
including standards, indicators and certification systems.
-
Training courses, manuals and materials including webinars on pertinent NBT topics,
including
tourism and visitor management, protected areas tourism, standards and interpretation.
-
Nearly 50 institutions, networks and information platforms supporting guidance on NBT
internationally.
Despite the diversity and depth of resources identified, some gaps remain, and it is clear
that many of the resources currently available are not widely known or used. Furthermore,
given the extensive and diverse resources identified in this report, it may be challenging
for
managers within and outside the World Bank to review and apply them.
Recommendations proposed to address these issues include the following:
-
Establish a technical focal point or unit on NBT
to provide targeted support technical guidance, and guide project managers towards the
most
appropriate resources or approaches. The focal point would:
-
Provide support to World Bank staff, clients and consultants involved in the design,
implementation or evaluation of projects to ensure that they are fully appraised of the
most
relevant best practice guidance in a particular destination, or under specific
circumstances.
-
Organize and facilitate webinars and trainings on specific topics on a regular basis,
in
conjunction with short briefing papers.
-
Develop a
‘one-stop’ platform for NBT tools and resources
that is comprehensive, easy to search, so that people can easily find and access
materials,
at little or no cost. The platform would on existing platforms and directories provided by
institutions such as the
World Bank
,
OnePlanet
,
IUCN
or alternatively through more general platforms such as
ResearchGate
and libraries that provide document hosting functions. As part of the platform, this
report
can be adapted to form an e-book, using the database of resources identified (see Annex 1).
-
Create
new tools and resources that are strategic and game-changing
, and also directly correspond with the needs that World Bank staff and clients have. The
priority themes are:
-
Overtourism and undertourism
, with practical tools and approaches that destination managers can apply quickly,
reliably
and in line with best practices.
-
Tourism concessions and investment,
including the completion and dissemination of planning and procurement tools and
templates,
coupled with training for World Bank staff and consultants.
-
Climate change and nature-based tourism
, with guidance to help natural destination managers, NBT operators, and
travellers, to
understand, avoid and mitigate climate change impacts.
-
Hunting,
to establish global standards for sustainable hunting, coupled with evidence of
its
impacts on
conservation and livelihoods and guidance that clarifies the differences between
illegal
poaching of wildlife and legal hunting.
“
More than the availability or otherwise of resources and tools, it
is
the awareness and use of existing tools by Bank project managers and specialists
where
greater effort is needed. Greater understanding of the critical nature of the
conservation dimension of nature-based tourism is needed, and guidance on how to
integrate this with project design
.”
|